All of the products shown above are cruelty free (excluding MAC).
Vegan options are cruelty free and vegan (no animal derived ingredients).
Smashbox’ “Girl Gang” is about $3 more expensive than the MAC product being duped, however I included it for anyone who wanted a dupe that that color or already had it.
As for the rest of the liquid lipsticks,they’re all pretty much comfortable and pigmented.
I will say that the Colourpop and Beauty Creations choices can be drying, so be sure to use a good lip moisturizer prior to applying either of these.
The Kleancolor choice has a bit of stick to it, so a non greasy lip balm should easily resolve this problem (greasy lip balms tend to make the product appear shiny and tranzfer with ease… they’re a super great tool to use when taking off waterproof liquid lipsticks)